Lack of data validation - Header x-amzn-RequestId
Need
Implementation of secure data validation for the x-amzn-RequestId Header
Context
- Usage of Ruby 2.0+ for developing Ruby applications
- Usage of ActionPack for handling web requests and generating responses in a Ruby on Rails application
- Usage of ActionController for handling actions and routing in a web application
Description
Non compliant code
class ApplicationController < ActionController::Base
before_action :set_request_id
private
def set_request_id
@request_id = request.headers['x-amzn-RequestId']
end
end
The above code demonstrates the vulnerability in question. It's a Ruby on Rails controller where we are extracting the 'x-amzn-RequestId' from the request headers and assigning it to an instance variable @request_id
.
Here, the application does not validate the 'x-amzn-RequestId' header value that it receives from the client. This means that an attacker could potentially send a harmful string in the 'x-amzn-RequestId' header, which could lead to various security issues such as SQL Injection, Cross-Site Scripting (XSS), or Remote Code Execution depending on how the @request_id
is used in the application.
The lack of input validation and sanitization is a common security issue. This is particularly dangerous when the input is used in a context that allows for command or query execution.
Steps
- Implement server-side validation for the x-amzn-RequestId header
- Define a whitelist of allowed characters for the x-amzn-RequestId header
- Validate the x-amzn-RequestId header against the whitelist of allowed characters
- Reject or sanitize any input that contains potentially dangerous characters
- Consider using a regular expression or a validation library to perform the validation
- Ensure that the validation is performed before using the value of the x-amzn-RequestId header
Compliant code
class ApplicationController < ActionController::Base
before_action :set_request_id
private
def set_request_id
request_id = request.headers['x-amzn-RequestId']
if valid_request_id?(request_id)
@request_id = request_id
else
# Handle invalid request_id as per your application's error handling strategy
# For example, you might want to log an error, raise an exception, or return a 400 response
end
end
def valid_request_id?(request_id)
# Define a whitelist of allowed characters for the x-amzn-RequestId header
# This is just an example, adjust the regular expression to match your requirements
allowed_characters = /\\A[a-zA-Z0-9\\-_]+\\z/
request_id.match?(allowed_characters)
end
end
The updated code includes a new method valid_request_id?
that validates the x-amzn-RequestId
header against a whitelist of allowed characters. The whitelist is defined as a regular expression, which in this example allows alphanumeric characters, hyphens, and underscores. If the x-amzn-RequestId
header contains any characters not in the whitelist, the valid_request_id?
method will return false
, and the set_request_id
method will not set the @request_id
instance variable.
This validation is performed before the value of the x-amzn-RequestId
header is used, preventing potentially dangerous character strings from being entered. If the x-amzn-RequestId
header is invalid, the set_request_id
method handles it according to your application's error handling strategy. For example, you might want to log an error, raise an exception, or return a 400 response.
This approach ensures that the application controls server-side permission to modify the x-amzn-RequestId
header, mitigating the risk of injection attacks.