Skip to main content

Inappropriate coding practices - Eval function

Need​

Secure handling of user input and avoidance of using the eval function

Context​

  • Usage of PHP for server-side web development
  • Usage of Illuminate\Http\Request for handling HTTP requests in Laravel
  • Usage of Illuminate\Http\Controller for handling HTTP requests and responses

Description​

Non compliant code​

<?php

namespace App\\Http\\Controllers;

use Illuminate\\Http\\Request;

class VulnerableController extends Controller
{
    public function executeCommand(Request $request)
    {
        $command = $request->input('command');
        eval($command);
    }
}

In the above code snippet, a VulnerableController class is defined in a Laravel application. This class has a method named executeCommand, which accepts a Request object as a parameter.

The executeCommand method retrieves a 'command' from the request input using $request->input('command'). This 'command' is then passed directly into the eval() function.

The eval() function in PHP is used to execute arbitrary PHP code. In this context, it's a serious security vulnerability because it's using user-provided data ($command) without any validation or sanitization. This means that an attacker could provide a 'command' that contains malicious PHP code, which would then be executed on the server when the eval() function is called.

This could lead to a variety of attacks, including code injection, data theft, data corruption, denial-of-service attacks, and even complete takeover of the server. Therefore, it's important to never use the eval() function with user-provided data, and to always validate and sanitize any user-provided data before using it.

Steps​

  • Remove the use of the eval() function. It's a dangerous function that can lead to code injection vulnerabilities.
  • Instead of executing the command directly, consider using safer alternatives. For example, if the command is meant to interact with the database, use prepared statements or ORM methods.
  • Always validate and sanitize user input. Never trust user input blindly. Use Laravel's validation methods to ensure the input is safe before using it.
  • Consider using a whitelist of allowed commands. This way, even if an attacker manages to inject a command, it won't be executed unless it's on the whitelist.
  • Implement proper error handling. Don't expose sensitive information in error messages.

Compliant code​

<?php

namespace App\\Http\\Controllers;

use Illuminate\\Http\\Request;
use Illuminate\\Support\\Facades\\Validator;

class SecureController extends Controller
{
    protected $allowedCommands = ['command1', 'command2']; // Add your allowed commands here

    public function executeCommand(Request $request)
    {
        $validator = Validator::make($request->all(), [
            'command' => 'required|in:' . implode(',', $this->allowedCommands),
        ]);

        if ($validator->fails()) {
            return response()->json(['error' => $validator->errors()], 400);
        }

        $command = $request->input('command');

        // Execute the command safely
        // This is just an example, replace it with your actual command execution logic
        switch ($command) {
            case 'command1':
                // Execute command1
                break;
            case 'command2':
                // Execute command2
                break;
            // Add more cases as needed
        }
    }
}

The updated code removes the use of the eval() function, which is a dangerous function that can lead to code injection vulnerabilities. Instead of executing the command directly, we are now using a switch statement to determine which command to execute. This is a safer alternative as it prevents arbitrary commands from being executed.

We have also added input validation using Laravel's built-in validation methods. The Validator::make() function is used to ensure that the 'command' input is present and is one of the allowed commands. If the validation fails, a JSON response with the validation errors is returned with a 400 status code.

The allowed commands are stored in the $allowedCommands array. This acts as a whitelist of commands that can be executed. Even if an attacker manages to inject a command, it won't be executed unless it's in this array.

This code also implements proper error handling. If the validation fails, an error message is returned in the response. This does not expose any sensitive information, making it safer than the previous code.

References​

Last updated on